Okuma S-8/9 Fly Reel Review
Our verdict
The Okuma S-8/9 fly reel earns its spot at $39.99 because it pairs an aluminum build with a 4.5 star rating across 139 reviews, a rare combination this far below the $48.46 Daiwa and the $449 Ross Reels Animas in the same 8/9 weight class.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anglers who want a dedicated 8/9 weight reel for heavier fly lines without paying saltwater-reel prices, and who are comfortable buying a lighter-reviewed model at 139 reviews instead of the 566-review Pflueger.
Skip if
Skip the Okuma S-8/9 if you fish lighter lines than 8/9 weight, since this reel is sized specifically for that heavier class, or if you want the largest review base available, where the 566-review Pflueger leads.
- Material Aluminum
- Weight 0.44 Pounds
- Technique Fly Fishing
- Size 8/9 WT
- Color Black
- Priced 14% below the category median ($46.73 across 20 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.5/5
4.5 average across 139 owner ratings
-
Popularity2.2/5
139 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Picture spooling up for a day chasing bass on 8 weight or 9 weight line and needing a reel that will not add unnecessary weight to the setup. The Okuma S-8/9 is built from aluminum and comes in at 0.44 pounds, a spec sized specifically for that 8/9 weight class rather than a generic one-size reel.
At $39.99, the S-8/9 undercuts the $48.46 Daiwa 00404230 and sits close to the $37.58 Pflueger 1149988, both of which also target fly anglers. Where the Pflueger uses a blend material and weighs 11.2 ounces in a one size format, and the Daiwa pairs its aluminum body with a semi-large arbor spool and click-drag system, the Okuma keeps things simple: aluminum, black, and sized for 8/9 weight line specifically.
The 4.5 star rating across 139 reviews sits above the Daiwa's 4.2 stars over 239 reviews and below the Pflueger's 4.4 stars over 566 reviews, though the Pflueger draws far more review volume. The $449 Ross Reels Animas rates higher at 5.0 stars, but across only 10 reviews, a sample too small to weigh heavily against three reels with more established track records. For anglers who need an 8/9 weight aluminum reel and want to spend under $40, the Okuma S-8/9 is a straightforward match.
Pros
- Aluminum construction for a build material that holds up better than blended composites.
- Priced at $39.99, undercutting the $48.46 Daiwa 00404230 in the same fly-reel category.
- 4.5 star rating across 139 reviews, ahead of the Daiwa's 4.2 stars over 239 reviews.
- Sized specifically for 8/9 weight line rather than a generic one size fit.
- Weighs 0.44 pounds, a clearly stated spec for anglers comparing reel weight.
- Listed as in stock, so it is currently available to order.
Cons
- Only 139 reviews compared to the Pflueger 1149988's 566, a smaller sample to judge consistency.
- No arbor size or drag system spec is listed, unlike the Daiwa's semi-large arbor spool and click-drag detail.
- Bought last month shows 0+, offering no signal on current purchase momentum.
- Limited to the 8/9 weight class, so it will not suit anglers who need a lighter or heavier reel.
- Comes only in black, without the color options some anglers may want.
Specifications
| Material | Aluminum |
|---|---|
| Weight | 0.44 Pounds |
| Technique | Fly Fishing |
| Size | 8/9 WT |
| Color | Black |
Performance notes
The S-8/9 designation tells most of the story: this reel is built around 8 weight and 9 weight fly lines, the range typically used for larger freshwater species and lighter saltwater work where a rod needs to move more line and turn over bigger flies. An aluminum body at 0.44 pounds keeps the reel light enough not to unbalance a rod built for that line weight, since anglers matching reel weight to rod weight generally want the pairing to feel neutral in hand rather than tip heavy or butt heavy. Compared to the Daiwa 00404230, which lists a semi-large arbor spool and click-drag system as named features, the Okuma's listing does not specify arbor size or drag type, so anglers who care about faster line pickup or a particular drag feel will need to look at the reel directly rather than relying on the spec sheet alone.
What buyers say
A 4.5 star average across 139 reviews puts the S-8/9 in solid territory, ahead of the Daiwa 00404230's 4.2 stars over a larger 239-review base and behind the Pflueger 1149988's 4.4 stars across 566 reviews. That gap in review volume matters: the Pflueger has accumulated nearly four times as many ratings, which generally means its average reflects a broader range of buyers and conditions. The Okuma's 139 reviews are fewer but still a meaningful sample, well beyond the 10 reviews behind the Ross Reels Animas' 5.0 star average. Bought last month is listed at 0+ for this reel, the same as most of its direct competitors here, so recent demand cannot be distinguished from the rating pattern alone.
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
What line weight does the Okuma S-8/9 fit?
The S-8/9 is sized for 8/9 weight fly line, the size range noted directly in its specs. That places it in the heavier freshwater and light saltwater bracket rather than the lighter trout-weight reels, so anglers should match it to a rod built for 8 or 9 weight line specifically.
How does the Okuma S-8/9 compare to the Daiwa 00404230 on price?
At $39.99, the Okuma S-8/9 costs less than the $48.46 Daiwa 00404230. Both use aluminum construction, but the Daiwa specifies a semi-large arbor spool and click-drag system while the Okuma's listing does not detail arbor size or drag type, so the price gap may reflect those added specifics.
Is the Okuma S-8/9 rated well against other fly reels?
Yes, its 4.5 star rating across 139 reviews beats the Daiwa 00404230's 4.2 stars over 239 reviews and comes close to the Pflueger 1149988's 4.4 stars across 566 reviews. Only the $449 Ross Reels Animas rates higher at 5.0 stars, though that is based on just 10 reviews.