Ross Reels Animas 4/5 Fly Reel - Matte Black Review
Our verdict
The Ross Reels Animas 4/5 carries a perfect 5.0 star rating, but that score comes from only 10 reviews, a small sample next to the 239 to 566 reviews behind its $37.58 to $48.46 rivals, so its $449 price tag needs to be judged on that limited data alone.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anglers who want a premium-priced fly reel and are comfortable relying on a 10-review sample with a perfect 5.0 star average, rather than the larger, more established review bases behind the $37.58 to $48.46 alternatives listed here.
Skip if
Skip the Animas 4/5 if $449 is out of budget, since the $37.58 Pflueger and $39.99 Okuma cover the same fly-reel category for a fraction of the cost, or if you want a rating backed by hundreds of reviews instead of just 10.
- Priced 861% above the category median ($46.73 across 20 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating5.0/5
5.0 average across 10 owner ratings
-
Popularity0.2/5
10 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Anyone shopping the top end of the fly reel market will notice the Ross Reels Animas 4/5 sitting well above the rest of this lineup at $449, more than nine times the price of the $37.58 Pflueger 1149988 and the $39.99 Okuma S-8/9. That price puts it in a different tier entirely, one where the reel is presumably marketed on materials and machining rather than budget-friendly value.
The listing does not provide a specs breakdown for the Animas 4/5 the way it does for the Daiwa 00404230, which names its aluminum body, 5.6 ounce weight, semi-large arbor spool, and click-drag system, or the Pflueger, which lists its blend material and 11.2 ounce weight. Without that detail, the Animas 4/5 has to be judged mostly on its price point and its rating.
That rating is a perfect 5.0 stars, but it rests on only 10 reviews, a small number next to the 239 reviews behind the Daiwa, the 566 behind the Pflueger, and the 139 behind the Okuma. A 5.0 average from 10 buyers is a promising early signal, not the kind of broad track record that a 4.4 average across 566 reviews represents. Anyone considering the $449 Animas 4/5 should weigh that gap in sample size against the premium price before deciding.
Pros
- Carries a perfect 5.0 star rating, the highest of any fly reel in this comparison.
- Positioned at the premium end of the category at $449, suggesting higher-grade materials or machining than the sub-$50 options here.
- In stock and currently available to order.
- Matte black finish is stated directly in the product name.
- 4/5 weight sizing is specified in the title for anglers who need that line class.
Cons
- Only 10 reviews back the 5.0 star average, far fewer than the 239 to 566 reviews behind cheaper alternatives.
- At $449, it costs more than 9 times the $37.58 Pflueger and $39.99 Okuma, without a listed spec sheet to justify the gap.
- Bought last month shows 0+, giving no indication of current demand.
- No material, weight, or drag system specs are listed, unlike the Daiwa 00404230's detailed spec sheet.
Performance notes
The Animas 4/5 designation places this reel at the lighter end of the fly weight spectrum, typically used for smaller freshwater species like trout on finer tippet, a different class from the 8/9 weight Okuma S-8/9 in this lineup. Unlike the Daiwa 00404230, which specifies an aluminum body, 5.6 ounce weight, semi-large arbor spool, and click-drag system, or the Pflueger 1149988, which lists a blend material and 11.2 ounce weight, the Animas 4/5 listing here does not break out material, weight, or drag type. At $449, the price alone signals a higher-end build than the sub-$50 aluminum reels in this comparison, but without a stated spec sheet, anglers cannot verify arbor size, drag system, or exact weight against that price the way they can with the Daiwa or Pflueger.
What buyers say
A perfect 5.0 star average is the standout number for the Animas 4/5, but it is drawn from just 10 reviews, a fraction of the 566 reviews behind the Pflueger 1149988's 4.4 stars or the 239 reviews behind the Daiwa 00404230's 4.2 stars. Small review samples can swing on a handful of satisfied buyers, so a 5.0 average from 10 people carries less statistical weight than a 4.4 average from 566. Bought last month is listed at 0+ here, matching every other reel in this set, so there is no purchase-volume signal to add context to the rating. The early pattern is positive, but thin.
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
Is the Ross Reels Animas 4/5's 5.0 star rating reliable?
It reflects a perfect average, but only 10 reviews back it, compared to 239 for the Daiwa 00404230 and 566 for the Pflueger 1149988. A small sample can still be accurate, but it has not been tested across as many buyers as the cheaper alternatives in this lineup.
Why does the Animas 4/5 cost so much more than other fly reels here?
At $449, it is priced well above the $37.58 Pflueger 1149988 and $39.99 Okuma S-8/9. The listing does not provide a spec breakdown to explain the gap, so the price likely reflects brand positioning and build quality that are not itemized in the data available here.
What line weight is the Ross Reels Animas 4/5 built for?
The name specifies 4/5 weight, a lighter class than the 8/9 weight Okuma S-8/9 in this comparison. That sizing typically suits smaller freshwater fly fishing rather than the heavier lines the Okuma and Daiwa reels are built around, so anglers should match rod weight to that same range before buying.