Scotty 0284-BK Rod Holder Review
Our verdict
The Scotty 0284-BK rod holder sells for $31.64, the highest price among the Scotty holders in this comparison, but it backs that up with a 4.7 star rating across 1,200 reviews and 300+ bought last month, the second-strongest demand figure in the group.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anglers who want a mid-weight Scotty holder at just under a pound and are comfortable paying a premium for a listing with strong recent demand, evidenced by 300+ units bought last month.
Skip if
Skip it if price is the deciding factor, since the $18.95 0280-BK and $24.95 230-BK both post the same 4.7 star rating for noticeably less money, and the 230-BK still outsells it at 400+ bought last month.
- Material Synthetic
- Weight 0.95 Pounds
- Color Black
- Pieces 1
- Feature Rod Holder
- Priced 27% above the category median ($24.97 across 84 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.7/5
4.7 average across 1,200 owner ratings
-
Popularity4.0/5
1,200 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Picture an angler comparing every Scotty holder available and deciding the newest or heaviest option is worth paying up for. The Scotty 0284-BK sits at $31.64, above the $26.92 0229-BK, the $24.95 230-BK, and the $18.95 0280-BK, making it the priciest holder in this set, and that price alone is enough to make most shoppers pause and check what the extra money buys.
It is built from synthetic material and weighs 0.95 pounds, just under a full pound, putting it close in heft to the 1-pound 230-BK and noticeably above the 14.4-ounce 0229-BK and 8-ounce 0280-BK. The listing lists it plainly as a rod holder without extra mount branding, so buyers are paying for weight and rating rather than a named mounting system.
At 4.7 stars across 1,200 reviews, it matches the top rating in this comparison while sitting on a mid-sized review pool, smaller than the 230-BK's or 0229-BK's 1,500 but larger than the 0280-BK's 702. Bought last month sits at 300+, behind only the 230-BK's 400+ and ahead of the 200+ seen on both the 0280-BK and 0229-BK, a demand pattern that tracks fairly closely with its position between the cheapest and priciest Scotty holders in this lineup.
Pros
- Ties the top 4.7 star rating found across this Scotty comparison
- 300+ bought last month, the second-highest demand figure here
- 1,200 reviews gives the rating a solid, sizable sample
- Near 1-pound synthetic build offers substantial material
- Currently in stock and ready to ship
Cons
- Most expensive Scotty holder in this comparison at $31.64
- Costs roughly $13 more than the equally rated $18.95 0280-BK
- Review count of 1,200 trails the 1,500 logged by the 230-BK and 0229-BK
- Demand of 300+ still falls short of the 230-BK's 400+ bought last month
Specifications
| Material | Synthetic |
|---|---|
| Weight | 0.95 Pounds |
| Color | Black |
| Pieces | 1 |
| Feature | Rod Holder |
Performance notes
At 0.95 pounds, the 0284-BK sits just shy of the 230-BK's full pound and well above the lighter 0280-BK and 0229-BK, which suggests a build closer in bulk to Scotty's heavier-duty holder rather than its lighter models. The plain rod holder feature description, without a side-mount or Powerlock label, mirrors the 0229-BK's simpler listing rather than the 230-BK's mount-specific branding. Priced at $31.64, it commands the highest premium of any Scotty holder here, roughly $5 above the next closest, the 0229-BK at $26.92. That premium is at least partly supported by its 4.7 star rating and 300+ monthly buyers, both stronger figures than the cheaper 0229-BK posts, even though the 0284-BK has not caught up to the 230-BK's review volume or sales pace.
What buyers say
A 4.7 star rating across 1,200 reviews puts the 0284-BK in a tie for the best score in this comparison, alongside the 0280-BK and 230-BK, while sitting on a review base larger than the 0280-BK's 702. The 300+ bought last month is a strong figure, second only to the 230-BK's 400+ and ahead of the 200+ recorded for both the 0280-BK and 0229-BK. Given that it is also the most expensive option here, that combination of a top rating and above-average recent demand suggests buyers are choosing it despite the higher price rather than because it is the cheapest way to get a 4.7 star Scotty holder.
More from Scotty
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
Is the Scotty 0284-BK worth the higher $31.64 price?
It carries a 4.7 star rating across 1,200 reviews and 300+ bought last month, both strong figures, but the $18.95 0280-BK matches the same star rating for about $13 less. The 0284-BK's case rests on its heavier 0.95-pound build and stronger current demand than the cheaper 0229-BK.
How does the 0284-BK's weight compare to other Scotty holders?
At 0.95 pounds, it is close to the 1-pound 230-BK and notably heavier than the 14.4-ounce 0229-BK or the 8-ounce 0280-BK. That places it among the sturdier builds in this comparison, second only to the 230-BK by a small margin.
Does the 0284-BK sell as well as the top Scotty holder in this group?
Not quite. It shows 300+ bought last month against the 230-BK's 400+, though it still outsells both the 0280-BK and 0229-BK, which each show 200+. Its 1,200 reviews also trail the 1,500 logged by those two Scotty models, despite matching their 4.7 star rating.