40
40 Pieces Fly Fishing Flies Fly Poppers Panfish Poppers Dry
$18.9950+ bought last month
View on Amazon
Synthfly Lifelike Mayfly Pack of 8 Mayflies for Fly Fishing Review
Our verdict
The Synthfly Lifelike Mayfly 8-Pack costs $29.95 for eight synthetic flies, which works out to roughly $3.74 per fly, well above the dozen-packs nearby. The 4.5-star average across 130 reviews backs the tying quality, but the per-fly math is the real story here.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Trout anglers who target specific hatch-matching mayfly patterns and want a small, curated set of synthetic flies in sizes 10, 12, and 14 rather than a bulk assortment of unrelated patterns.
Skip if
You fish often enough to lose flies to snags and trees regularly, since at roughly $3.74 per fly this pack empties your fly box faster than a $7.99 dozen would for the same money.
- Material synthetic
- Weight 0.02 Kilograms
- Target Species Trout
- Technique J Hook
- Size 10, 12, 14
- Color Yellow,Gray,Green,Brown
- Priced 216% above the category median ($9.49 across 12 tracked models)
Our scorecard
4.4/5
overall
-
Owner rating4.5/5
4.5 average across 130 owner ratings
-
Popularity1.7/5
130 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Synthfly's Lifelike Mayfly pack ships eight synthetic flies for $29.95, aimed squarely at trout anglers working a mayfly hatch. Each fly weighs about 0.02 kilograms in the packaging and comes in sizes 10, 12, and 14 with a J hook, giving anglers some room to match different mayfly stages without buying separate boxes for each size.
The color spread covers yellow, gray, green, and brown, which lines up with common mayfly body tones seen on freshwater trout streams through a season. That range suggests the pack is built as a rotating hatch-matching kit rather than a single-pattern bulk buy, which fits the lower piece count of eight compared to the 12-piece Adams 1010 set sitting nearby in the same price bracket of flies.
At $29.95 for eight flies, the math works out to about $3.74 per fly, compared to roughly $0.67 per fly on the Adams 1010 twelve-pack and the classic Adams dozen, both priced at $7.99. The 4.5-star rating across 130 reviews and 50-plus recent purchases show the pattern has a real following, but buyers are clearly paying for synthetic material, size range, and color variety rather than sheer fly count.
Pros
- 4.5-star average across 130 reviews shows consistent buyer satisfaction
- Three sizes in one pack (10, 12, 14) covers different mayfly life stages
- Four colors (yellow, gray, green, brown) match common trout stream hatches
- Synthetic material is built for repeat casting rather than natural fibers
- 50-plus bought last month indicates steady, current demand
- Lightweight at 0.02 kilograms, easy to carry a full set in a small fly box
Cons
- At $29.95 for 8 flies, the per-fly cost is about $3.74, well above the $0.67 per fly on the Adams dozen
- Only 8 pieces per pack versus 12 on the Adams 1010 at less than a third of the price
- No listed material breakdown beyond synthetic, so exact tying construction is unclear
- Higher price makes losing flies to snags a costlier mistake than with budget dozens
Specifications
| Material | synthetic |
|---|---|
| Weight | 0.02 Kilograms |
| Target Species | Trout |
| Technique | J Hook |
| Size | 10, 12, 14 |
| Color | Yellow,Gray,Green,Brown |
| Pieces | 8 |
Performance notes
The size range of 10, 12, and 14 on a J hook covers the common mayfly imitation window for trout, letting an angler size down as a hatch progresses without switching packs. The four color options, yellow, gray, green, and brown, mirror the body tones seen across mayfly species through a season, so the pack functions more like a small hatch-matching kit than a single go-to fly. At 0.02 kilograms total, weight is a non-issue for carrying in a vest or small fly box. The synthetic build is the tradeoff for the higher per-unit price. It is a durability bet rather than a volume bet, since eight flies is a light count for anglers who fish often enough to lose flies to trees, rocks, or break-offs during a normal outing.
What buyers say
A 4.5-star average across 130 reviews is a strong showing for a specialty fly pack, and 50-plus units bought last month shows the listing keeps moving rather than sitting stale. Compared to the Adams dozen at 4.4 stars across 292 reviews and 100-plus bought last month, the Synthfly pack has a smaller but still healthy review base for its price point. The rating pattern suggests buyers who choose this pack know they are paying a premium for color variety and sizing options, and the volume of purchases indicates it holds a steady niche among trout anglers rather than being a one-off impulse buy.
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
- Adams
Adams Assortment Trout Fishing Flies (1-Dozen) Black
$7.99100+ bought last monthView on Amazon
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
How much does the Synthfly Lifelike Mayfly 8-Pack cost per fly?
At $29.95 for 8 flies, each one works out to roughly $3.74. That is notably higher than the Adams dozen or Adams 1010 twelve-pack, both priced at $7.99, which land closer to $0.67 per fly, so this pack suits selective buyers, not volume buyers.
What sizes and colors are included in this pack?
The pack includes sizes 10, 12, and 14 on a J hook, in four colors: yellow, gray, green, and brown. That spread is meant to cover different mayfly stages and common trout stream hatch tones in one compact set for a single vest pocket.
Is the 4.5-star rating reliable given the price?
With 130 reviews and 50-plus units bought last month, the 4.5-star average reflects a real, ongoing customer base rather than a handful of early reviews. It is a smaller sample than the Adams dozen's 292 reviews, but still a solid volume.