Berkley BTBMP-AST1 Fish Attractant Review
Our verdict
The Berkley BTBMP-AST1 fish attractant earns its keep at $16.42, backed by a 4.6 star average across 4,000 reviews, the second highest review count of any Berkley attractant in this lineup. With 1,000+ units bought last month, it sits behind only the $6.97 Berkley 1004950 in monthly demand, making it a proven pick rather than a gamble.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anglers who already trust Berkley's scent lineup and want a mid-priced attractant with a track record, since 4,000 reviews at 4.6 stars and 1,000+ monthly buyers put it well above niche, unproven options.
Skip if
Skip it if the price is the deciding factor, since three other Berkley attractants in this comparison cost less, from $4.56 to $6.97, and one of them, the 1004950, outsells this one at 2,000+ a month.
- Priced 74% above the category median ($9.43 across 42 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.6/5
4.6 average across 4,000 owner ratings
-
Popularity4.6/5
4,000 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Picture restocking a tackle bag before a weekend trip and facing four Berkley branded attractants at wildly different prices. The BTBMP-AST1 sits at the top of that price range, $16.42, more than three times the cost of the cheapest option in this lineup, the $4.56 BTCOY2.
That premium has to be justified by something, and the review data backs it up somewhat. At 4.6 stars across 4,000 reviews, the BTBMP-AST1 matches the top rating in the group and trails only the 1004950's 5,900 reviews and the BTCOY2's 4,600 in total review volume. It is not the most reviewed attractant on this list, but it is far from thin on feedback, and its rating holds steady with the best of the field.
Monthly demand tells a similar story. Berkley reports 1,000+ units bought last month for the BTBMP-AST1, more than the BTCOY2's 700+ and the GCN's 200+, though still behind the 1004950's 2,000+. For anglers who want a proven, higher-end Berkley attractant and are not chasing the lowest sticker price, the BTBMP-AST1 lands as a solid middle-tier pick backed by real sales volume.
Pros
- 4.6 star average across 4,000 reviews, matching the highest rating in this Berkley lineup
- 1,000+ units bought last month, more demand than the $4.56 BTCOY2's 700+
- Ranks third by review volume among the four Berkley attractants compared here, still a large sample
- Currently InStock with no availability gaps noted
- Priced within the same brand family as three other well-reviewed alternatives, making side-by-side comparison straightforward
Cons
- At $16.42, it costs more than three times the $4.56 BTCOY2 without a listed spec sheet to justify the gap
- Falls behind the 1004950 in both review count, 4,000 versus 5,900, and monthly sales, 1,000+ versus 2,000+
- No material, weight, or target species specs are listed for this ASIN, unlike the context alternatives
- Is not the cheapest way to get a 4.6 star Berkley attractant
Performance notes
There is no published material, weight, or target species breakdown for the BTBMP-AST1 in the data available, so judging it comes down to price positioning and review behavior rather than a spec sheet. At $16.42, it sits well above the three Berkley alternatives in this comparison, which range from $4.56 to $6.97, suggesting a larger container, a specialty formula, or a multi-pack, any of which would explain the higher per-unit cost without a full description confirming it. The 4.6 star rating across 4,000 reviews puts it on par with the best-rated options here, and 1,000+ units bought last month is a meaningful volume for a single ASIN, signaling this is not a slow-moving or niche listing even at the higher price point. In practice, that combination of steady rating and strong monthly demand is a reasonable proxy for a product that performs as expected for repeat buyers.
What buyers say
A 4.6 star average holding across 4,000 reviews is a large enough sample that the rating is unlikely to be a fluke, and it matches the top score in this Berkley grouping rather than trailing it. Combined with 1,000+ units bought last month, the pattern reads as a product with sustained repeat demand rather than a one-time spike. It does not outsell the 1004950's 2,000+ monthly buyers or its 5,900 reviews, so it is the second choice by pure volume in this specific comparison, but a 4.6 star average at 4,000 reviews is still a strong signal that buyers are getting what they expect at this price.
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
How does the Berkley BTBMP-AST1 compare in price to other Berkley attractants?
At $16.42, it costs more than the BTCOY2 at $4.56, the GCN at $5.62, and the 1004950 at $6.97, all Berkley branded attractants in this comparison. The gap is significant, more than triple the cheapest option, so buyers should weigh whether the higher cost fits their budget before choosing it over the cheaper alternatives.
Is the BTBMP-AST1's 4.6 star rating reliable given the review count?
Yes. A 4.6 star average across 4,000 reviews is a large sample size, matching the top rating among the four Berkley attractants compared here. Only the BTCOY2, with 4,600 reviews, and the 1004950, with 5,900 reviews, have more feedback, so the rating is well supported rather than based on a handful of early reviews.
Does the BTBMP-AST1 sell as well as other Berkley attractants?
It sells well but not the best in this group. Berkley reports 1,000+ units bought last month for the BTBMP-AST1, ahead of the BTCOY2's 700+ and the GCN's 200+, but behind the 1004950's 2,000+. That places it as a strong second-tier seller rather than the top mover in this specific lineup.