102
102 Supreme, Rotary Fly Tying Vise - Practical Fly Fishing
$22.9950+ bought last month
View on Amazon
SF TF0102BKC1 Fly Tying Tool Review
Our verdict
The SF TF0102BKC1 Fly Tying Tool costs $6.99, the lowest price among the fly tying tools compared here, but its 4.0 star rating across 50 reviews is also the weakest in the group. With 100+ bought last month, it still moves at a steady clip despite trailing the Dr WF4 and Orvis on rating.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Budget minded anglers who want the cheapest tool in this comparison and do not mind a rating half a star below competitors, or who are buying a backup rather than a primary tool.
Skip if
Anglers who prioritize rating over price should skip this one. At 4.0 stars it trails every other fly tying tool in this comparison, including the $7.94 Dr WF4 rated 4.5 stars for barely more money.
- Priced 30% below the category median ($9.99 across 21 tracked models)
Our scorecard
4.0/5
overall
-
Owner rating4.0/5
4.0 average across 50 owner ratings
-
Popularity1.0/5
50 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Picking a fly tying tool off a shelf of near identical looking options usually comes down to two numbers: price and rating. The SF TF0102BKC1 wins on the first and loses on the second.
At $6.99 it is the cheapest tool in this comparison, a dime under the HOOK-EZE 1 Pack at $7.99 and cheaper still than the Dr WF4 at $7.94, the Orvis 4P620000 at $19.95, and the Colorado Z797 at $41.85. But its 4.0 star rating across just 50 reviews is the lowest of the group, well behind the Dr WF4's 4.5 stars and the Colorado Z797's 4.4 stars. It also trails the Orvis 4P620000's 4.1 stars, making it the only tool in this comparison rated below 4.1.
The 100+ bought last month figure shows the low price still pulls in steady buyers, and a 50 review sample is not nothing, but it is thin next to the Orvis's 125 or the Colorado Z797's 1,500. InStock availability means the tool ships without delay despite its budget pricing. For anglers who weigh price heavily, the SF tool is worth a look. For anyone chasing the highest rated option, the Dr WF4 costs five cents more and rates half a star higher.
Pros
- $6.99 price is the lowest of any fly tying tool in this comparison
- 100+ units bought last month shows the price point attracts steady buyers
- InStock availability with no backorder wait
- Compact single tool format for a tackle bag or vest
- Priced a full dollar under the Orvis 4P620000 despite a similar function
Cons
- 4.0 star rating is the lowest among the four tools compared here
- 50 review count is the smallest sample size in the group
- No listed material, weight, or size specs
- Rated 0.5 stars below the Dr WF4, which costs only 5 cents more
Performance notes
The SF TF0102BKC1 listing does not include a material, weight, or size, so there is little to go on beyond the price and the review pattern. That puts it in the same position as the HOOK-EZE 1 Pack, which also ships without published specs. By contrast, the Dr WF4 lists a Natural material construction, a 4 inch frame, and a Brass color for $7.94, and the Orvis 4P620000 specifies a tippet material build, a 5 ounce weight, and a 4x1 inch size for $19.95. Without a spec sheet to lean on for the SF tool, the 4.0 star rating becomes more important context. It suggests a tool that functions but leaves more buyers less than fully satisfied than its pricier, better documented competitors.
What buyers say
A 4.0 star rating is workable but it is the lowest figure in this comparison, sitting a full 0.4 stars behind the Colorado Z797's 4.4 and 0.5 stars behind the Dr WF4's 4.5. With only 50 reviews behind it, the average is also the least statistically stable of the group, built on a fraction of the Colorado Z797's 1,500 review base. Still, 100+ units bought last month is a solid number for a $6.99 item, suggesting the low price keeps demand alive even if the rating alone would not stand out on its own.
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
Is the SF TF0102BKC1 the cheapest fly tying tool available?
Among the tools compared here, yes. At $6.99 it undercuts the HOOK-EZE 1 Pack at $7.99, the Dr WF4 at $7.94, the Orvis 4P620000 at $19.95, and the Colorado Z797 at $41.85, making it the lowest priced option in this set.
How does the SF tool's rating compare to competitors?
Its 4.0 star rating across 50 reviews is the lowest among the tools in this comparison. The Dr WF4 rates 4.5 stars across 185 reviews, the Colorado Z797 rates 4.4 stars across 1,500 reviews, and the Orvis 4P620000 rates 4.1 stars across 125 reviews, all ahead of the SF tool.
Does the SF TF0102BKC1 list material or size specs?
No material, weight, or size figures are listed for this product. Buyers wanting documented specs might look at the Dr WF4, which lists a Natural material, 4 inch size, and Brass color, or the Orvis 4P620000, which lists a tippet material and 5 ounce weight.