3 P58564-1 Tackle Box Review
Our verdict
Priced at $33.24, matching the Plano 1155-03 exactly, this P58564-1 Tackle Box carries a 4.2 star rating across 154 reviews and 200+ bought last month, a demand figure that beats every Plano competitor but a rating that trails all three by a notable margin.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Budget conscious anglers who want a black polypropylene box at the same price point as the Plano 1155-03 and don't mind a somewhat lower average rating in exchange for stronger recent purchase activity.
Skip if
Skip this if rating consistency matters most to you, since this box's 4.2 stars is the lowest among the comparable priced alternatives, which all sit at 4.6 to 4.7 stars.
- Material Polypropylene
- Color black
- Priced 39% above the category median ($23.89 across 66 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.2/5
4.2 average across 154 owner ratings
-
Popularity1.1/5
154 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
This P58564-1 Tackle Box is priced at exactly $33.24, matching the Plano 1155-03 dollar for dollar, and is built from black polypropylene, a durable plastic commonly used for impact resistant cases. That price match makes for a clean head to head comparison against an established Plano product at the same cost.
On rating, the two diverge. This box holds a 4.2 star average across 154 reviews, while the Plano 1155-03 at the identical price posts 4.7 stars across 619 reviews, both a higher rating and a review count four times larger. That gap suggests buyers have been somewhat less satisfied on average with this listing compared to its direct price match competitor.
Where this product does lead is current demand. Bought last month sits at 200+, double the 100+ figure reported for the Plano 1155-03 and every other Plano box in this comparison. That combination, a lower rating but stronger recent purchase volume, at an identical price point to an established competitor, suggests the product is gaining traction with buyers even though its satisfaction scores haven't yet caught up to the category leaders.
Pros
- 200+ bought last month is double the 100+ figure posted by every Plano competitor in this comparison
- Priced at $33.24, an exact match to the well established Plano 1155-03
- Polypropylene construction is a durable, impact resistant plastic material
- 154 reviews gives the rating a moderate sample size to draw from
- Black color option offers a simple, utilitarian finish
Cons
- 4.2 star rating is the lowest in this entire comparison, trailing the 4.6 to 4.7 range of the Plano alternatives
- 154 reviews is well below the 619 to 1,600 review range behind the Plano competitors
- No stated weight or piece count, leaving capacity and compartment layout unclear
- At the same $33.24 price as the Plano 1155-03, buyers get a lower rating for the same money
- Limited spec detail compared to competitors that list weight and piece count
Specifications
| Material | Polypropylene |
|---|---|
| Color | black |
Performance notes
Polypropylene is a commonly used, impact resistant plastic in tackle box construction, generally comparable in durability to the materials used across the Plano lineup, though the listing doesn't specify wall thickness or latch design. Without a stated weight or piece count, it's difficult to gauge how this box's internal layout or overall heft compares to the 1.2 to 4.2 pound range and 1 to 24 piece counts seen on the competitors in this set. At $33.24, the price puts it squarely against the Plano 1155-03, which does list a 4.2 pound weight and single piece construction, so buyers weighing these two directly should note the missing spec detail here as a gap in available information rather than a confirmed shortfall.
What buyers say
A 4.2 star average across 154 reviews is the lowest rating among all products in this comparison, sitting noticeably below the 4.6 to 4.7 stars posted by the three Plano boxes, even though the review count of 154 is a reasonable sample, if smaller than the 619 to 1,600 range those competitors carry. At the same time, 200+ bought last month doubles the 100+ figure reported for every Plano alternative, indicating stronger current purchase momentum despite the comparatively softer rating. That combination, weaker satisfaction scores paired with stronger recent demand, suggests a product that is selling well on price or availability even as it hasn't matched the review sentiment of the established competition.
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
How does the price compare to the Plano 1155-03?
It's priced identically at $33.24, making this a direct dollar for dollar comparison, though the Plano 1155-03 carries a higher 4.7 star rating across a much larger 619 review sample versus this box's 4.2 stars across 154 reviews.
What is this tackle box made of?
The listing specifies black polypropylene construction, a durable and commonly used impact resistant plastic, though specific details like weight and internal compartment count aren't provided in the available specs.
Is the lower rating a dealbreaker given the strong recent sales?
That depends on priorities. The 4.2 star rating is the lowest in this comparison, but 200+ bought last month is double the figure for competing Plano boxes, suggesting current buyers are choosing it despite the comparatively softer review sentiment.