Columbia 183681 Fishing Hat Collegiate Navy/Fish Flag Review
Our verdict
The Columbia 183681 Fishing Hat costs $30.00 and carries a recognizable brand name, but its 4.2 star rating rests on just 5 reviews, the smallest sample of any hat in this comparison, even though 100+ units sold last month shows some active demand.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anglers who trust the Columbia name and want a cotton-built cap with a fish flag design, and who are comfortable buying a listing with only 5 reviews on record so far.
Skip if
Buyers who rely on review volume to judge reliability should be cautious here, since 5 reviews is far too small a sample to compare meaningfully against hats like the Home hat's 10,800 or even the ZOORON's 1,879.
- Material Cotton
- Color Collegiate Navy/Fish Flag
- Pieces 1
- Priced 77% above the category median ($16.99 across 121 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.2/5
4.2 average across 5 owner ratings
-
Popularity0.2/5
5 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Picture wanting a hat from a name you already trust on the water, even if the specific listing is new. The Columbia 183681 Fishing Hat leans on that brand recognition, priced at $30.00 in a cotton build with a Collegiate Navy colorway and a fish flag design. The fish flag graphic is a design detail none of the plain sun hats in this comparison offer.
That price sits close to the $29.99 Outdoor Solar Fan Hat and well under the $75 Sunday VCHLCS, though it is the only hat in this set made from cotton rather than nylon or polyester. Cotton breathes differently than synthetic fabrics and tends to absorb more moisture, a tradeoff worth weighing against the nylon options here.
Its 4.2 star rating matches the Wide SFH-0426's score, but it rests on only 5 reviews compared to that hat's 84, making it the thinnest sample in this entire comparison. Bought last month sits at 100+, tying the Sunday VCHLCS despite that hat's far larger 3,118 review base, a pattern that suggests early but real interest in a newer listing. That said, a 4.2 average built on so few reviews can shift quickly with just a handful of new ratings, unlike the more established scores elsewhere in this comparison.
Pros
- Columbia is a recognizable outdoor brand name, distinct from the generic-sounding listings elsewhere in this comparison
- 100+ bought last month ties the Sunday VCHLCS despite that hat costing more than double at $75
- Fish flag graphic and Collegiate Navy colorway offer a design detail not found on the plain sun hats compared here
- Cotton construction is the only one of its kind in this comparison, an alternative to the nylon and polyester builds elsewhere
- 4.2 star rating matches the Wide SFH-0426's score at a comparable price point
Cons
- Only 5 reviews back the 4.2 rating, the smallest sample by far in this entire comparison
- $30.00 price is close to the top of this comparison's range, well above the $8.32 to $16.99 budget options
- Cotton absorbs more moisture than the nylon used on most other hats in this set
- With so few reviews, the 4.2 average could shift significantly as more ratings come in
Specifications
| Material | Cotton |
|---|---|
| Color | Collegiate Navy/Fish Flag |
| Pieces | 1 |
Performance notes
Cotton is the only fabric of its kind among the hats compared here, where nylon and polyester dominate. Cotton tends to breathe well in dry heat but holds onto moisture longer than synthetic fabrics once it gets wet, a relevant tradeoff for anglers who expect spray or rain on the water. The Collegiate Navy/Fish Flag colorway adds a graphic design element, differentiating it from the solid-color, function-first hats like the Home or ZOORON listings. At $30.00, the price sits mid-pack, above the budget nylon hats but well under the $75 Sunday VCHLCS. No UPF rating is listed in the specs here, so sun-blocking performance is not confirmed the way it is on the TOP-EX and Rosoz hats, which state UPF 50+ directly.
What buyers say
A 4.2 star rating sounds middling next to the 4.5 to 4.7 scores on the higher-review hats in this comparison, but the context matters here more than usual. Only 5 reviews back that average, compared to thousands for most rivals, so the score is not yet statistically meaningful in the way a 4.7 across 10,800 reviews is. The 100+ bought last month figure is a more useful signal, tying the $75 Sunday VCHLCS and suggesting real, if modest, current demand for a listing that is still building its review history. Buyers should weigh the brand name and recent purchase activity more heavily than the thin rating here.
More from Columbia
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
- Cow
Cow Print Bucket Hat Cute Bucket Hat Beach Fisherman Hat
$9.99100+ bought last monthView on Amazon
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
Can I trust the Columbia 183681's 4.2 star rating?
Treat it cautiously. The rating is based on only 5 reviews, far fewer than the thousands backing most other hats in this comparison. It is not necessarily unreliable, but a sample this small can shift with just a few more reviews, so it carries less weight than a 4.7 built on 10,800 reviews.
What material is the Columbia fishing hat made from?
It is built from cotton, the only cotton hat among the options compared here, versus the nylon and polyester builds on the others. Cotton breathes well in dry conditions but holds moisture longer once wet, worth considering for anglers who expect spray or rain.
Is the Columbia 183681 worth $30 compared to cheaper fishing hats?
At $30.00, it costs more than the $8.32 to $16.99 budget hats in this comparison, but it adds brand recognition, a fish flag graphic, and cotton construction none of those cheaper options offer. Whether that is worth it depends on how much a recognizable name and design detail matter to the buyer.