Scotty 0229-BK Rod Holder Review
Our verdict
The Scotty 0229-BK rod holder is priced at $26.92, the highest of the three Scotty options compared here, yet its 4.6 star rating trails the 4.7 stars posted by both the cheaper 0280-BK and 230-BK. It still moves 200+ units a month, so demand exists, but the numbers favor the less expensive alternatives.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anglers already invested in Scotty's synthetic-bodied lineup who want the 14.4-ounce 0229-BK specifically, or who prioritize its particular mount configuration over squeezing out the last dollar of value.
Skip if
Skip it if pure rating and price matter most, since the $18.95 0280-BK and the $24.95 230-BK both post a 4.7 star average for less money. Also skip it if you want the highest-volume Scotty holder, a title held by the 230-BK.
- Material Synthetic
- Weight 14.4 ounces
- Color Black
- Pieces 1
- Feature Rod Holder
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.6/5
4.6 average across 1,500 owner ratings
-
Popularity4.5/5
1,500 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Picture an angler comparing three Scotty rod holders side by side, expecting the priciest one to also be the best rated. The Scotty 0229-BK complicates that assumption. At $26.92 it costs more than the $18.95 0280-BK and the $24.95 230-BK, yet its 4.6 star rating sits a tenth of a point below both, a small gap but a consistent one worth flagging before checkout.
Built from synthetic material at 14.4 ounces, it lands between the 8-ounce 0280-BK and the 1-pound 230-BK on weight. The listing describes it simply as a rod holder, without the Powerlock or side-mount branding attached to the 230-BK, which may indicate a more basic mounting setup. Anglers who already own compatible Scotty deck hardware are the most likely audience for this particular model.
It matches the 230-BK's review volume at 1,500, so the 4.6 versus 4.7 star gap is not a small-sample fluke. Bought last month sits at 200+, tying the 0280-BK but running well behind the 230-BK's 400+. Against the $15.99 Sea 27-2P at 4.6 stars and 1,000 reviews, the 0229-BK matches on rating but charges roughly $11 more, which is a tough case to make on value grounds alone, even before weighing the two cheaper Scotty models sitting right beside it in the lineup.
Pros
- 1,500 reviews gives the 4.6 star rating a large, stable sample size
- 200+ bought last month shows continued demand
- Synthetic build at 14.4 ounces offers more material than the 8-ounce 0280-BK
- Simple, unbranded rod holder design without extra mount hardware to account for
- Currently in stock
Cons
- Most expensive of the three Scotty holders compared, at $26.92
- 4.6 star rating trails the 4.7 stars posted by both the 0280-BK and 230-BK
- Monthly demand of 200+ is half the 400+ recorded for the 230-BK
- Costs about $11 more than the similarly rated $15.99 Sea 27-2P
- No side-mount or Powerlock feature listed, unlike the 230-BK
Specifications
| Material | Synthetic |
|---|---|
| Weight | 14.4 ounces |
| Color | Black |
| Pieces | 1 |
| Feature | Rod Holder |
Performance notes
At 14.4 ounces, the synthetic body of the 0229-BK sits in the middle of this Scotty comparison, heavier than the 8-ounce 0280-BK but lighter than the 1-pound 230-BK. The listing's plain rod holder feature tag, without any side-mount or Powerlock designation, suggests a more basic hardware package than the 230-BK, which references a 0241 side mount directly in its title. That simpler setup does not appear to translate into a rating advantage, since the 0229-BK's 4.6 stars sits below the 4.7 stars posted by both other Scotty models in this set despite matching the 230-BK's 1,500-review sample size. The price of $26.92 is the highest of the three, which puts more weight on whatever specific fit or feature reason a buyer has for choosing it over the cheaper options.
What buyers say
A 4.6 star average across 1,500 reviews is still a strong pattern in absolute terms, but placed next to the 4.7 stars both the 0280-BK and 230-BK carry on similar or larger review pools, it reads as the weaker performer of the three Scotty holders here. The 200+ bought last month matches the cheaper 0280-BK exactly, which suggests buyers are not paying the roughly $8 premium for extra sales velocity. The 230-BK's 400+ monthly figure, double this one, further underlines that the market seems to be favoring the other two Scotty options at this price tier.
More from Scotty
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
Why does the $26.92 Scotty 0229-BK rate lower than cheaper Scotty holders?
The listing does not explain the gap directly, but the 0229-BK holds a 4.6 star average across 1,500 reviews while the $18.95 0280-BK and $24.95 230-BK both post 4.7 stars. The difference is a tenth of a point, small but consistent across a large review sample.
Is the 0229-BK still worth buying at $26.92?
It still sees 200+ units bought last month and carries a large 1,500-review base, so it is not a poor seller. But buyers focused purely on rating and price may find better value in the 4.7 star 0280-BK or 230-BK, both priced lower.
How does the 0229-BK's weight compare to other Scotty holders?
At 14.4 ounces, it sits between the 8-ounce 0280-BK and the 1-pound 230-BK. That middle-of-the-road weight comes with the highest price of the three, at $26.92, so it does not offer a clear light-weight or heavy-duty advantage over the alternatives.