Automatic 2PACK automatic fishing rod holder Review
Our verdict
The Automatic 2-Pack fishing rod holder sits at $24.99 with a 4.3-star average across 389 reviews, a respectable showing but not a chart-topper. Its rubber and stainless steel build covers two rods per pack, yet Scotty's 230-BK matches the price with a 4.7-star rating over 1,500 reviews and stronger demand at 400+ bought last month.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Anglers who want a two-rod holder set with a stainless steel and rubber build for around $25, and who don't mind a newer listing without the multi-thousand review history of established brands like Scotty.
Skip if
Skip this if you already own a Scotty 230-BK or 0280-BK, since both carry more reviews, a higher 4.7-star rating, and stronger monthly sales at a comparable or lower price point.
- Material Rubber, Stainless Steel
- Pieces 2
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.3/5
4.3 average across 389 owner ratings
-
Popularity3.2/5
389 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other fishing gear and tackle we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
Picture two rods propped against a cooler while you re-bait a hook, one gust of wind or a rocking boat and you're fishing one out of the water. That's the scenario the Automatic 2-Pack fishing rod holder is built to solve, giving each rod its own dedicated slot instead of a shared lean-to.
The set is built from rubber and stainless steel, a combination meant to grip rod blanks without scuffing the finish while resisting rust in wet conditions. At $24.99 for two holders, it lands in the middle of this category's price range, cheaper than buying two single-unit Scotty holders separately but pricier than the budget Sea 27-2P.
Against the competition, the numbers tell a mixed story. The Automatic 2-Pack holds a 4.3-star rating across 389 reviews and 100+ bought last month, solid but modest next to the Scotty 230-BK's 4.7 stars over 1,500 reviews and 400+ monthly purchases at almost the same price. The Sea 27-2P undercuts it by $9 with a higher 4.6-star rating, though on fewer than half the review count of the market leader. For anglers who prioritize a two-pack setup over single-unit flexibility, the Automatic still fills a real need, just without the review depth of the established names.
Pros
- Comes as a matched 2-pack, covering two rods for $24.99 instead of buying single holders twice.
- Stainless steel components resist rust better than painted metal alternatives.
- Rubber contact points cushion rod blanks against scuffing.
- 4.3-star average across 389 reviews shows generally positive feedback.
- 100+ bought in the last month indicates steady, active demand.
- Priced under the Scotty 230-BK while offering two holders instead of one.
Cons
- 389 reviews is a fraction of the Scotty 230-BK's 1,500, meaning less long-term track record.
- 4.3-star rating trails all three listed competitors, which all sit at 4.6 or 4.7 stars.
- 100+ bought last month is the lowest demand figure among the compared holders except the Sea 27-2P.
- No mounting hardware details are listed beyond the rubber and stainless steel materials.
- At $24.99, it costs more than the Sea 27-2P without matching its per-unit review volume.
Specifications
| Material | Rubber, Stainless Steel |
|---|---|
| Pieces | 2 |
Performance notes
The rubber and stainless steel combination is a practical pairing for a rod holder that will live outdoors. Stainless steel resists the corrosion that saltwater spray and humidity cause in cheaper coated metals, so the holder's structural parts should hold up over repeated seasons without visible rust bleeding through paint. Rubber at the contact points serves a different job: cushioning the rod blank so it doesn't rattle or scuff against a hard surface every time a boat rocks or a truck bed bounces down a gravel road. Being sold as a 2-pack means both mounting points are covered in one purchase, which matters if the goal is running two setups, say a bait rod and a jigging rod, side by side. Compared to the single-unit Scotty holders, which require buying two separate units to match this coverage, the 2-pack format is the main practical differentiator here rather than any exotic material or engineering.
What buyers say
A 4.3-star average across 389 reviews puts this holder in solid but unspectacular territory, the kind of rating that suggests most buyers get what they expect without a wave of complaints. It's meaningfully lower than the 4.6 to 4.7 stars posted by all three comparison holders, and the review count is thinner too, especially against the Scotty 230-BK's 1,500. The 100+ bought last month figure shows the listing is actively moving, just not at the pace of the Scotty 230-BK's 400+ or the 0280-BK's 200+. Read together, the pattern points to a product that satisfies its buyers reasonably well but hasn't built the review depth or repeat-purchase volume that the category's established names have accumulated over time.
More from Automatic
Similar fishing gear and tackle to consider
Featured in
Frequently asked questions
How many rods does the Automatic 2-Pack hold?
The set includes two separate holders, so it secures two rods at once for a combined $24.99. That works out to roughly $12.50 per holder, which is cheaper than buying two Scotty 0280-BK units separately at $18.95 each, though the Scotty carries a higher 4.7-star rating across 702 reviews.
Is stainless steel better than the plastic used in some Scotty holders?
Stainless steel generally resists rust and corrosion better than untreated plastic, especially in saltwater environments where painted or plastic parts can degrade over repeated seasons. The Scotty 0280-BK and 230-BK use plastic and synthetic materials instead, which keeps them lighter but may show wear sooner in harsh, salt-heavy conditions.
Does the 4.3-star rating mean this holder is a downgrade from competitors?
Not necessarily. A 4.3-star average across 389 reviews still reflects mostly positive feedback, just with a smaller sample and slightly lower ceiling than the 4.6 to 4.7 stars seen on the Sea 27-2P and both Scotty models. Buyers focused on getting two holders in one purchase may still find it a reasonable fit.